Insights

A Support-Only Subsidiary in Korea Still Needs a Profit

Funding a support-only subsidiary: without a charge and with a charge Without a charge, the Korean subsidiary provides support services to head office and the question is whether anything is charged for them; head office sends capital or loans, and the subsidiary records costs only and a loss every year. With a charge, the subsidiary invoices head office its costs plus a margin, head office pays a monthly service fee, and the subsidiary pays its running costs from those fees. Three questions follow: would an unrelated company have charged, what margin stays in Korea, and is the subsidiary funded by capital, loans or service fees. FUNDING A SUPPORT-ONLY SUBSIDIARY WITHOUT A CHARGE Head office Korean subsidiary ! No charge? Support services Capital or loans Costs only, a loss every year WITH A CHARGE Head office Korean subsidiary Costs + margin Monthly service fee Running costs paid from fees KEY QUESTIONS 1 Would an unrelated company have charged? 2 What margin stays in Korea? 3 Capital, loans, or service fees?

Foreign companies preparing to enter Korea often plan a subsidiary that will not sell anything itself. It will research the market, find customers and look after local partners. At that stage we hear one question again and again: if the Korean company earns no revenue of its own, can it simply spend the money head office sends?

The answer is no. Even a subsidiary that only supports head office should charge head office for its work, and that charge should leave a profit in Korea. There are two reasons: tax, and the flow of money.

An unrelated company would have charged

The work a Korean support subsidiary does for head office is usually market research, customer development, account management and help with trade shows and events. Imagine the same work done for a company with no connection to yours. It would have been invoiced, and the invoice would not have stopped at the costs incurred. A margin would have been added on top. No business works for others at cost.

Korean tax law applies the same test to transactions between related companies, such as a parent and its subsidiary. They are expected to deal at an arm’s length price – the price unrelated parties would have agreed. If the subsidiary works for nothing, or for its costs alone, because the client happens to be its parent, the profit that should have arisen in Korea is treated as having been shifted to head office.

Without a profit, the tax authorities supply one

A Korean subsidiary that spends year after year and reports a loss each time looks, to the tax authorities, like a company that worked in Korea and earned nothing there. In that case the authorities can recompute the consideration the subsidiary should have received at an arm’s length price and charge corporate income tax on the difference. Because the arrangement repeats every year, several years can be raised at once, with penalty tax on top.

In practice, a subsidiary in a support role commonly charges head office its selling, general and administrative costs plus a margin of around 5 to 10 percent. The margin need not be large. What matters is that a profit commensurate with the work done in Korea stays in Korea. The right rate depends on what the subsidiary actually does, so it is best settled when the structure is first designed.

The subsidiary has to be funded anyway

Tax aside, the charging structure is needed for a simpler reason. A Korean subsidiary has salaries, rent and running costs to pay every month. Without revenue, that money can only come from head office, and there are broadly two ways to bring it in.

  • Capital increase – raising the share capital. Each increase means going through the foreign direct investment notification and court registration again.
  • Loans from head office – borrowing the money. Borrowing from abroad has its own foreign exchange reporting, and each interest payment raises a withholding question. Korea also has thin capitalisation and interest limitation (earnings stripping) rules: where a foreign-invested company’s borrowing is excessive relative to its equity, or its interest expense is excessive relative to its income, the interest above the limit is not allowed as a deduction.

A monthly service fee charged to head office works differently. Consideration for the work arrives on a regular basis and pays for the Korean operation, and every remittance has a clear basis as payment for services. For tax and for funding alike, it is the most natural structure.

What to put in place

  • An intercompany agreement – setting out which services are charged and on what basis.
  • The calculation – a record showing which costs the margin was applied to. Costs paid on head office’s behalf that simply pass through are usually recharged at cost, separately and without a margin.
  • VAT – whether zero-rating applies to the service fee charged to head office has to be checked against its conditions. If they are not met, ten percent VAT can be assessed.

A subsidiary that only supports head office is still not a company that can run without revenue. An unrelated company would have charged for the same work, and the work done for head office deserves consideration and a profit on the same standard. Settling the charging structure and the margin when the company enters Korea reduces the tax risk and keeps the cash flowing. For a review of how your Korean subsidiary charges head office, please contact Star Tax & Legal at heebong@star-tax.kr.

Topics: Transfer Pricing · Head Office Charges · Intercompany Recharges · Withholding Tax · Corporate Compliance

Professionals

Hee-Bong Park

Hee-Bong Park

CPA, Partner

heebong@star-tax.kr

Song I Yoon

Song I Yoon

CPA, Director

siyoon@star-tax.kr

Does your Korean subsidiary charge head office for its work?

Contact Us